Debating the merits of stick vacuums versus corded vacuums: What's the superior choice?
Modern cordless stick vacuums have gained widespread popularity, with CHOICE issuing numerous reviews on them. The surge in interest can be traced back to 2018 when Dyson announced its decision to forsake traditional corded vacuums in favor of battery-powered models, signaling a shift in the market. Even established brands like Miele and tool manufacturers such as Ryobi and Makita have ventured into the cordless vacuum realm.
In testing, CHOICE has observed significant improvements in cordless stick vacuum performance since their initial assessment in 2010, particularly on carpet. Many high-end models even outperform their corded counterparts in this area. However, it's important to note that performance can vary with some of the cheaper stick vacuums proving no match for traditional vacuums.
When weighing the CHOICE verdict, paying top dollars for a premium stick vacuum may serve as a replacement for a corded barrel or upright model if maintenance and emptying the vacuum less frequently is not a concern. For extensive cleaning, traditional vacuums, especially barrel or upright models, may be a more cost-effective and suitable solution for large homes.
Many users prefer the best of both worlds, incorporating corded and cordless vacuums into their cleaning routine, using the corded model for large clean-ups and the stick vacuum for daily spills and dust management.
In terms of performance on hard floors, cordless stick vacuums generally deliver impressive results, with the average test score being a healthy 76%. However, there are some that score as low as 10%, so it's essential to check individual product reviews if your home predominantly consists of hard floors.
Vacuum type
Although corded vacuums have stopped being tested on hard floors due to their consistent performance, stick vacuums often come with soft/fluffy head attachments designed for better pick-up on hard floors.
Thorough cleaning on carpet
In terms of maintenance, cordless stick vacuums have smaller dustbins, necessitating more frequent emptying. Maintaining optimal performance requires regular emptying of the bin and cleaning of filters, some of which can be somewhat fiddly. Some manufacturers like LG, Samsung, and Shark offer automatic cleaning models that empty the dust from the vacuum's bin into a larger dust bag when placed on their charging docks.
Quick cleaning on carpet
Corded vacuums, on the other hand, generally have a far greater dust capacity, averaging about 1.9L. Both types of vacuums require similar maintenance when it comes to maintaining filters, cleaning brush heads, and removing tangled hair.
When it comes to removing pet hair, both vacuum types can perform admirably. However, pet hair can build up in the brush heads of stick vacuums, making frequent emptying necessary, which may be inconvenient for individuals suffering from allergies.
Stick (cordless)
Some stick vacuums may struggle with pet hair littering the carpet, especially older models. Pets shedding hair can also be caught in the brush heads, but traditional vacuums tend to pick up pet hair more effectively.
70%
Stick vacuums are superior in ease of use due to their lightweight design, averaging just 2.8kg compared to 7kg for traditional models. This makes navigating the house and cleaning cars simpler. Additionally, they can be quickly converted into handheld units for tackling tight spaces and above-floor cleaning.
63%
While traditional vacuums excel in several aspects, cordless stick vacuums offer convenience due to their cordless nature and ease of maneuverability. Swappable batteries can facilitate more extended runtime, but a constant power source provided by traditional vacuums offers reassurance. Both types of vacuums are similarly noisy, with average noise levels of around 73dB to 74dB.
In terms of value, stick vacuums can be costly, with some models exceeding $1200, while traditional vacuums tend to be more affordable, with a median cost of around $374 for corded models. However, it's essential to remember that not all stick vacuums are expensive, and some budget options can deliver great results.
Traditional (corded barrel/upright)
Overall, cordless stick vacuums are an attractive solution for convenience, portability, and ease of storage, making them suitable for quick or spot cleaning and homes with less carpeted area. On the other hand, traditional barrel and upright vacuums provide better value for comprehensive whole-home cleaning needs, particularly where carpet cleaning depth and large area coverage are priorities.
73%
Ultimately, the choice between cordless stick vacuums and traditional vacuums depends on user preferences, cleaning needs, home size, flooring type, and priorities for portability versus cleaning power.
66%
In the realm of modern cleaning appliances, cordless stick vacuums present an attractive option for individuals seeking convenience due to their portability and ease of storage. These gadgets with technology advancements have shown significant improvements in performance, especially on carpets. However, for extensive cleaning tasks in larger homes predominantly covered with hard floors, traditional vacuums might prove more cost-effective and suitable.
