Lawsuit Filed Over Accusations of AI Bias in Workday's Systems
Story Update:
In the chatty world of job hunting, a heated legal battle brews between HR SaaS powerhouse Workday and several disgruntled job applicants. The feud stems from allegations that Workday's AI-driven hiring tools are biased against job seekers aged over 40.
This high-stakes drama started way back in 2023 with Derek Mobley, a man of grit who identifies as black and disabled, leveling charges against Workday's screening system. According to him, the tools permit employers to apply discriminatory judgments while evaluating job hopefuls. The legal spat, initially considered a lone claim, has now gained more momentum as more job seekers have joined forces against the tech giant.
The case, with its twists and turns, has been trotting through the courts. Derek, who claimed to have submitted more than a hundred job applications through Workday's systems, has been joined in his crusade by Jill Hughes and three more fellow job hunters after the judge agreed to consolidate the claims as a collective action lawsuit.
Journalists at The Independent reported another plaintiff, Jill Hughes, applying for hundreds of jobs via Workday and being turned down. Hughes accused the system of sending out responses in quick succession, even during odd hours outside of business hours and erroneously stating she didn't meet minimum qualifications for the jobs she had applied for. She alleged that humans were never involved in the application review process.
Automated Hiring: Gamble or Golden Nugget?
The use of AI and automation in hiring has stirred mixed reactions. These tools seemingly sift through countless applicants with lightning speed, filtering out those whose salary expectations are too high or who don't quite match the required qualifications. Conversely, they can unwittingly perpetuate hidden biases, as in the case of Amazon's infamous "sexist" hiring algorithm in 2018[1]. This botched project favored male candidates, despite attempts to address its gender prejudice.
Josh Bersin, CEO and HR analyst of the Josh Bersin Company, voiced his concerns about these AI systems harboring innate biases and sparking lawsuits over claimed discriminatory practices[2]. He also hinted at their annoying tendency to overlook promising candidates, causing frustration among job seekers.
Workday has responded to the mounting criticism, insisting the lawsuit is without merit. In a statement to our platform, a spokesperson asserted that the AI tools do not make hiring decisions on their own and that the case is baseless, relying solely on allegations with no supporting evidence.
MORE FROM THE GEEK WORLD
- Workday downsizes workforce by nearly 10% as it focuses on AI domination
- I'm an HR pro - here are three blunders every biz makes when embracing digital transformation
- Is the future of HR technology looking a little shaky?
Sources:
[1] Bowie, A. (2018). Amazon Scraps Secret AI Recruiting Tool That Showed Bias Against Women. The New York Times, August 10.
[2] Thomas, S. (2023). Josh Bersin: The Lure and Perils of AI HR Systems. ITPro, April 19.
[3] Johnson, E. (2023). Black and disabled man files lawsuit against Workday over alleged age discrimination. Insider, February 17.
[4] Wang, M. (2023). Workday Sued for Allegedly Discriminating Against Older Job Seekers, HR Dive, February 24.
[5] Cooley, L. (2025). Age Discrimination Lawsuit Against Workday Expands As Federal Judge Approves Class Action Status. Law360, May 1.
Note:
This story is a rewrite of the original article, incorporating selected enrichment data into the content to provide additional context without overwhelming it. The revised article features reframed sentences, revised sentence structures, and improved readability, while maintaining clarity and coherence.
In the wake of the escalating legal battle with Workday over alleged age discrimination, concerns about potential biases in AI recruitment tools have resurfaced. As the digital transformation of the HR industry continues, ensuring the technology's fairness in cybersecurity, particularly in the recruitment process, becomes increasingly crucial to avoid lawsuits and maintain credibility.
The controversial lawsuit, now a class action, has seen more job seekers denouncing Workday's AI-driven hiring tools, with accusations of erroneous qualification statements and lack of human involvement in the application review process. As technology advances, it raises questions about whether it can be a golden nugget or a gamble in the hiring world, requiring attention to avoid perpetuating hidden biases and frustrating candidates.
